Skin PATCH survey results
The survey of products for camouflaging hands has been a joint venture undertaken by the Vitiligo Society and the British Association of Skin Camouflage. The survey addresses the problem that traditional camouflage washes off too easily for use on the hands.Volunteers tested 10 products over the course of 6 months during 2014. The products are all readily available in the UK, but not on prescription. The following is the text of a presentation given by Liz Allen of the British Association of Skin Camouflage (BASC) at the Vitiligo Society Open Day in November 2014.
At BASC, we have known since the 1950s that camouflage is a great support mechanism for people with vitiligo and other skin problems but we are also aware it may create vulnerability most notably over hands and other salient areas because it quickly washes off and can be easily removed with emollients (including some sun blocks). It can also soil clothing, paper or even computers and mobiles. Embarrassingly, it may also transfer to another person when we shake their hand. If this rubbing off could be overcome, the potential would be enormous.
The Idea Behind the Survey
BASC knew that faux tans might help, but had no evidence to judge their effectiveness. We also knew that faux tans are designed for skin groups 1 and 2 and not for everyone. Then, sometimes the finger of fate takes a hand (excuse the pun). In September 2011 Jennifer Viles accepted the BASC’s invitation of a bursary and attended our training event (so that the Vitiligo Society could provide its own camouflage service for its members), the FIRST THING she said was how do we keep camouflage on hands? Discussions followed and we decided that a PATCH Survey would help to define the problems.
Preparations for the Survey
Our preparations included speaking to the manufacturers of faux tans, theatrical products and long-lasting cosmetics. We caught their curiosity sufficiently for them to supply products for the trial. Their only requirement was that there would be no comparisons made between the brands and that their brand would remain anonymous. Since we intended that the PATCH Survey would not be brand comparative, we were more than happy to agree these conditions. To ensure blind testing Norma Bird of the Vitiligo Society and Liz Allen of BASC spent many hours decanting seven of the ten brands used into identical plain bottles. (The other three products were not in liquid format).
Starting the Survey
Having secured equal funding from both the BASC and Vitiligo Society, we recruited participants. 34 people volunteered at the launch on 17th August 2013. 9 were from skin groups 3-6 and 25 were from skin groups 1-2. We also added Liz Allen to act as a control – someone who does not have vitiligo. Participants were each allocated a unique number, which meant that Pam Davison who analysed the results, had no idea who said what; neither did she know the brand identities. We were delighted that 32 of the volunteers stayed with us throughout the six month long survey and returned their questionnaires on time.
Results 1: Medical History Outcomes
Diabetes and Thyroid
There is a rumour that faux tan does not stain the skin of someone who has vitiligo and is also diabetic. Various experts could not suggest any medical reason to explain this. So,to resolve everyone’s curiosity, we included questions relating to the participants medical history. We got very excited when the only diabetic participant reported that two brands lasted 3 and 10 hours respectively…but then any hope that we had stumbled upon a medical implication was dashed because the other three faux tan brands tested had a duration of between 2-3 days each. As the participant had stated an overactive thyroid too, could this be a contributing factor? Curiously, seven others also had an over or under active thyroid, who reported the durability of the faux tans as,
– duration between 1-7 days (6 with underactive thyroid)
duration between 1-3 days (1 with overactive thyroid)
Other Medical Histories Outcomes
One participant with epilepsy reported that all brands lasted 2 days. One participant with high cholesterol reported that all brands lasted 1 to 4 days and two participants with arthritis reported one brand as lasting 15 hours whilst others lasted 2½ to 4 days. Of the three participants with psoriasis, two stated two brands washed off immediately but the other brands lasted a minimum of 2 and a maximum of 6 days (so we assume desquamation of plaques did not have an effect) Of six participants with hypertension two stated two brands washed off after a few hours but all stated the other brands duration was a minimum of 2 days and a maximum of 7 days. Fifteen participants stated that they had no medical condition (other than vitiligo) of which one person reported that one faux tan brand did not take at all, that 3 other products lasted 2-5 hours, but one brand over 24 hours.
Given the results, we concluded that there was no evidence that the duration of a faux tan was affected by other medical conditions.
Results 2: The Effects Of Hand-Washing
Camouflage is easily removed with soap and water, so we asked how many times participants washed their hands each day. Everyone used toilet soap (either liquid or tablet), some of which might contain antibacterial properties, and a few used wet wipes. We had no method of measuring how surgeon scrub-up practices are, or if the usual areas (including fingertips) were missed, as reported in the Journal of Community Nursing (Vol. 28 no.2 2014 – The importance of hand hygiene in preventing the spread of infection).
There did not seem to be any relationship between longevity of faux tan products and frequency of washing hands. Indeed, the participant who washed their hands up to 30 times each day still achieved a faux tan duration of 2 to 3 days! But, predictably, hand hygiene affected the stability of the other products tested.
Results 3: Usability
Not knowing who would volunteer, we created an equal number of trial sets for Skin Groups 1 to 3 and Groups 4 to 6. The survey responses confirm no significant differences between the skin groups. We did not anticipate any product would be an acceptable skin match, but for half the participants this was so!
Questionnaires-Product numbered was a traditional skin camouflage creme with powder and fixing spray applied to the volunteer at the launch day. Those numbered b 4 5 & 6 were theatrical and long lasting cosmetics; faux tans were numbered 1 2 3 7 & 8. Volunteers received an equal mix of cosmetics-faux tans to both 3-monthly trial periods.
On average the theatrical products and traditional skin camouflage creme and powder took very little time to dry; faux tans took twice as long, or longer. A dissatisfaction with faux tans was the time taken for a colour to develop instant colour (seeing the final colour) was preferred.
All the products issued had a brush applicator, so it was no surprise that the favourite applicator was the pen. BASC appreciates that people prefer to have precision control when applying their camouflage, and that blanket cover by aerosol or similar method is quicker when application is to a large lesion or whole arm or legs.
The general view was that all products smelled pleasant, or were acceptable. However, there were a few exceptions who considered some faux tans smelled of chemicals. Ten participants did not like the feel of camouflage-powder and fixing spray on their hands, but consensus was that overall the other products had a nice texture and were pleasant to use.
Results 4: Durability
As we expected, everything lasted longer than traditional camouflage even when it was for just six hours because six hours is a night out; six hours is a serious shopping trip; six hours is nearly a day’s employment
Now we have the evidence to take back to the manufacturers and to ask them to consider making longer lasting cosmetics and faux tans in natural skin colours. At the time of going to print, BASC have spoken to FOUR manufacturers-distributors involved, and they have agreed to explore expanding their colour range. Additionally, two manufacturers who were not involved have indicated to BASC that they, too, will consider creating faux tans that mimic the natural colour of all skin groups. We’ll let you know how these exciting developments progress.
The PATCH Survey could not have taken place without the support of all involved, especially our happy band of volunteers!
So a big THANK YOU to all.